Friday, January 25, 2013

Week Two - Essential Question

image from http://theeducatorsroom.com/
What tools might provide me insight into the learners in my classroom and how might I use this information?

Let me start out by saying that over the years I've had a lot of training on learning styles AND differentiated instruction. I've even done quite a bit of PD about differentiated instruction.  With that said, I'll also say that the end result of this experience is that I don't rely too much on the learning styles theories.  I have taken many of these surveys myself. The end result? It depends... That result is true of most students as well.  I think how well we learn really depends on many factors - like;
1. what time of day it is
2. if we are warm/cold, hungry/sated
3. if we are with a group of people who inspire us - or don't 
4. if we feel welcome, accepted, valued - or not
5. if we have a reason to care about what we are supposed to be learning about
6. if the task is asking too little, or too much of us 
7. if we have short attention spans
8. if we are asked only to be receptive but not to participate

And even when we are offered a variety of modalities to learn with;


1. visual presentations aren't always good
2. written presentations aren't always well-written
3. audio presentations aren't always dynamic
4. hands-on experiences aren't always meaningful or challenging

I believe the best way to differentiate is to put as much of the control for learning into the students' hands as they are able to handle at a given time.  I know that right now calling ourselves "facilitators" or "guide on the side" is fashionable - and I definitely agree with this re-framing of our roles. But we also need a clear understanding of what a facilitator really does. As facilitators, the most important thing we need to understand about our students is what they are ready for.  After that, we need to tend to the items 1-8 in my first list, as much as we are able, to make sure their learning conditions are as optimal as we can make them. And, we need to know about many different types of tools we can show them, that will give them choice and autonomy, hopefully spark some curiosity and creativity, and build independence and confidence. These traits are what we need most to "facilitate", to help our students take control of their own learning. 

I think this comes down to a combination of personalizing their learning AND differentiating.  Right now these are educational buzzwords with some ambiguity attached to what they mean exactly, but I like this chart created by Barbara Bray and Kathleen McClaskey in their post Personalization vs. Differentiation vs. Individualization. They have explained some of the subtle differences well. I don't necessarily think one is always better than another, and often our own limitations of time and workload may dictate which approach we choose, but as teacher/facilitators, I think we need to be aware of each, and tend to each. 
To answer the question, "what tools will help me do this?", I would have to say a healthy list of technology tools that help students explore, create, organize, communicate, and explain would be a good start.  Beyond that, doing what you can to stay in touch with your students and keep "knowing" them;
1. talk to them - often - not just about school - be interested in them as people, not just students
2. get to them in the morning - ask how their day is going
3. ask them questions about their learning as they learn - metacognitive conversations are helpful!
4. being a facilitator means being observant - don't just note what they are learning, figure out how they are learning.

As a colleague of mine often says, "Look at your students, not your lesson plans."

4 comments:

  1. Dear Tracie,

    What a great post your wrote this week! The last sentence sums up the whole issue. We have to feel students and know them well first. Your first factors list is amazing You tapped into the most important part of solution. It is the emotional side of students. I prefer to give myself enough time to feel my students through my eyes. The body language, facial expressions and gestures are the common language that we can use to reach each other.

    Thanks so much Tracie for sharing your ideas and reflections. If you have time, please visit my week 2 post and leave a comment to me: Know your Students before ...

    All the best!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Azhar - I find that teaching "how" to differentiate to other educators is often difficult, because there really is no one right way to do it. Something I often hear these days is "education is messy", and it is so true. There are some things that just defy simplification! I will check out your blog :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh, yeah baby, love that last sentence! With all this MOOC stuff, the next thing you know education will evolve into "humanistic instruction" in which teachers will actually have to visit with their students face to face! Wait for it......

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for your blog post, Tracie. I have so much to learn from you! One of the things I enjoy most about teaching is figuring out how each of my students learns, but it is also one of my greatest challenges.

    Two factors from your first list challenge me:
    5. if we have a reason to care about what we are supposed to be learning about
    6. if the task is asking too little, or too much of us

    As a teacher, I want to become more skillful at giving students a reason to care about what they are learning and at adjusting the tasks to meet them where they are. I would like to learn more about the best ways to accomplish that second skill without relying too heavily on standardized testing.

    Thank you for giving me so much to think about!

    Anne

    ReplyDelete